Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza in New York City

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza in New York City
4.2
50reviews
View phone 12122135558

493 2nd Ave, New York City, NY 10016-9130, New York City

Overview

Restaurant Hours

Monday

08:00 - 17:00

Tuesday

08:00 - 17:00

Wednesday

08:00 - 17:00

Thursday

00:00 - 17:00

Friday

00:00 - 17:00

Questions and answers

View all q&a

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
FA

Falling Angel Xtrava

google
11.20.2024
1/5

Found a roach in my food.

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
ES

Eric Sanny P

google
11.03.2018
4/5

Can't beat the price for sloppy NY slices. 1 dollar for a slice of cheese pizza. No frills. No seats. Cash only. ATM inside.

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
dn

dolpika nilima

google
10.14.2018
5/5

The best value-pizza you can find in Murray hill/kips bay

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
HL

Håkon Larsen

google
10.14.2018
2/5

Quick pizza. Not very good, and prizes they adverize is not correct.

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
MC

Michael Corado

google
09.16.2018
5/5

Best dollar slice!’

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
MM

Magdalina Montero

google
09.10.2018
5/5

😱OMG!!! This is the best pizza place and to top it off they're only $1 each. The crust is nice and thin, it has plenty of sauce and cheese. I'll buy a few slices and take them home to Brooklyn NY instead of buying a few slices in my neighborhood, that's how great it is! I highly recommend you go and at least try it.

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
AF

Andrew Flores

google
09.04.2018
5/5

Best ‘two slices and a soda’ special in the city!

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
VP

Vince PeGan

google
09.02.2018
5/5

One of the best $1 spots in the city

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
KF

Ken Fairbrother

google
08.19.2018
5/5

Insane! The pizza was way bigger than I thought it would be and tasted amazing well worth the price. A tourist to NYC and this is EXACTLY the kind of New York pizza you should get from a local and friendly pizzaria!

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
GH

Grant Hightower

google
08.09.2018
1/5

Hours are wrong online. Paid for a Uber at 9:30 when they were supposed to close at 12. They would not even come to the door to speak to me.

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
JS

Jessica SC

google
07.27.2018
5/5

Best 1$ pizza you can get! Way better than 99 cent express places. I'd say this is comparable to Joe's Pizza.

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
DM

Dexter Murray

google
07.07.2018
4/5

Fast and efficient. Hardly any waiting. I had two regular slices of pizza.

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza

Nando

google
06.13.2018
5/5

Good pizza, cheap. Don't expect the best pizza ever, but it's solid for the price

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
DM

Diana Mohr

google
05.27.2018
5/5

Was visiting New York City and they were a block from our apartment. Great pizza and cheap!

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
MC

Michael Corado

google
05.22.2018
5/5

The best value-pizza you can find in Murray hill/kips bay. Counter guy is great too!

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
IM

Ian Moffat

google
05.14.2018
5/5

8 bucks for a whole plain pie or 12 for a pepperoni. Tasty as sir tasty as.

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
DA

Darnell Auguste

google
05.10.2018
5/5

These Slices held me down like a "Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle". Great one dollar slice of pizza can't go wrong eating here if you're in the lower East side of NYC.

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
EH

Eliot Hilaire

google
05.08.2018
4/5

Best dollar slice I've had

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
MA

Michael Akke

google
04.17.2018
5/5

This place always comes through. Consistently good pizza. For the price you can't beat it.

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
NB

Nono Buck

google
04.13.2018
5/5

Best pizza in town taste great mouth watering prices is good won't hurt the pockets you have to grab some soda and maybe 4 or 3 slices and you are good you have to try there Buffalo slices and sausage as we'll I recommend this place to any one I give them a 4 a rating so if you near here go and check them out and don't forget to grab me 3 slices as well so until them enjoy your self peace

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
OE

Omari Emanuel

google
02.24.2018
5/5

Great food! Great bartenders and great service all around!!! So make it your duty to get here and experience it for yourself!!!!!!

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
CB

CRYPTO BMF

google
02.04.2018
5/5

You can’t go wrong!

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
co

carla osorio

google
01.05.2018
4/5

$1pizza slice, was good, friendly staff

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
OK

Oleg Korneitchouk

google
01.01.2018
5/5

Excellent dollar slice spot

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
NT

Neroshan Thevakumaran

google
11.14.2017
4/5

One of the best dollar slice shops in the area. They have patties and garlic knots as well, but it's the pizza that makes this place.

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
GW

G White

google
11.07.2017
5/5

Unbeatable. Love Joey peps!

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
DR

Damon Ramos

google
10.24.2017
5/5

Best dollar pizza in NYC!

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
SK

Sharon Kapitula

google
10.22.2017
4/5

$1 slices, $2.75 for two and a can of soda (plain cheese). Cash only. Good for the price, pick up and go.

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
F&

Food & Water Music

google
10.05.2017
5/5

Excellent and fast service! Great pizza by the slice or whole! Delicious and great prices!!! Thanks Joey Pepperoni!!!!!

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
KD

Kman Da Great

google
08.25.2017
4/5

Weird shape pizza, but very tasty. Fast service. Better than $1 pizza in NYC lol

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
IM

Itay Madenfrost ADV

google
07.26.2017
4/5

Nice local pizza. The owner is so nice !!!!

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
JA

Josue Arias

google
07.19.2017
4/5

It's great and has many available options

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
MC

Matt Chabot

google
07.04.2017
5/5

Got a fresh pie for our party and it was a hit for so cheap!

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
HC

Hailey Chan

google
07.01.2017
5/5

Hi there I’m Hailey

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
VW

Vanessa Ward

google
06.27.2017
1/5

Ehhh. I've given this place multiple chances. :/There's better not much farther down the street (23rd&7th). Just cause it's a buck doesn't mean you should settle for mediocre pizza. Walk the extra few blocks. Earn that pizza, lol. There's another really great $1 pizza joint behind the Chrysler building next to St.Agnes. It's so worth the hike.👌🍕🗽

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
PB

Phil Burton

google
06.08.2017
5/5

Awesome pizza, thought 2 Bro’s was good but Joey you just tip it! Well done!!!

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
hT

harold Thorpe

google
06.02.2017
5/5

Always great pizza and service!

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
CE

Cris Escobar

google
05.12.2017
5/5

Quick service and the food is always great

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
os

oliver smith

google
04.15.2017
4/5

This place is amazing...great in and out option..they are clean always. The size of pizza is bigger than others so that's cool.

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
Jh

Johnny hot

google
03.16.2017
5/5

Very respectful and nice people.

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
AB

Alan B Hunter Sr

google
02.06.2017
3/5

Great price, good pizza.

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
GP

Gerry Pion

google
10.25.2016
4/5

Pizza was great, the price better, but there was one guy at the counter doing everything and a long line ensued. Of one the workers seemed to be intoxicated and some vagrants were hanging out in front of the door...

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
MI

Monique Isaac

google
10.22.2016
4/5

1.00 pizza. Poor woman's treasure! I rely on this place when I'm busted. Decent staff, no frills.

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
FM

Floyd Martin

google
09.26.2016
4/5

Best pizza in new York for a dollar a slice dude.

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
LB

Lewis Berger

google
07.20.2016
5/5

Joey Pepperoni has been feeding this broke college student for 3+ years now. Best bang for your buck by far. Yes, it has its off days but you can NOT get a more filling better tasting meal for the same price

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
GM

Gabriel Motola

google
06.14.2016
5/5

One of the best dollar slices in Manhattan! I actually met Joey Pepperoni himself last time I was at the restaurant - great guy!

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
JL

Jordan Laland

google
06.12.2016
1/5

I saw a rat! Absolutely disgusting establishment. I can see why it’s $1 pizza

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
DF

David Fillmann

google
05.23.2016
5/5

For what you get for your money, there's no way I can't give this place 5 stars. Stayed at my friends college in the city on a tight budget for a few days and I was definitely impressed. One of the best tasting dollar pizza places in the city. For a dollar the pizza is great tasting, you'd be hard pressed to find better tasting food this cheap anywhere else in manhattan.

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
KN

Katrina Noyes

google
05.09.2016
4/5

Good! And good price!

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza
JC

Johnny Cruz

google
02.17.2016
2/5

Decent for a dollar.

Joey Pepperoni`s Pizza in New York City

493 2nd Ave, New York City, NY 10016-9130, New York City

4.2
50

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 12122135558

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!